News · legal — By WATMM Desk —

NVIDIA's NVentures asks a court to block UMG and Sony's demand for testimony in the Suno case

NVentures, NVIDIA's venture arm, has asked a federal court in California to quash a subpoena from UMG and Sony that would make it put up a witness in their lawsuit against Suno. It says it is a passive minority investor with no board seat that has already handed over 6,324 documents. The labels want its due diligence, licensing-cost and growth analyses, which could put a number on training rights that has not come out in court.

Key facts

  • What happened: on 10 Nov 2026 NVentures filed a motion in the Northern District of California (3:26-mc-80342) to quash, or narrow, a deposition subpoena that UMG, Capitol Records and Sony served in UMG Recordings v. Suno (1:24-cv-11611, D. Mass.).
  • What the labels want: corporate testimony on 10 remaining topics, including NVentures' pre-investment dealings with Suno, its diligence on Suno's training data, its analyses of licensing costs and growth, its views on Suno's effect on the music industry, and its communications with Suno about litigation risk over training data.
  • Why it matters: investors' diligence files are where an AI company's risk and the cost of licensing get written down in plain numbers. If the labels get them, investors in AI music companies can expect the same demand in the next case.

NVIDIA's venture arm doesn't want to sit for a deposition in the labels' lawsuit against Suno. On 10 Nov 2026 NVentures asked the federal court for the Northern District of California to quash a subpoena from UMG, Capitol Records and Sony, or at least narrow it. Its argument fits in one line from the motion: the labels would "turn a passive minority investor into a source of testimony about the defendant's conduct and the economics of an entire industry."

What do UMG and Sony want from NVentures?

A Rule 30(b)(6) deposition, which means NVentures must send someone to testify for the company as a whole. The motion says the subpoena is dated 17 Aug 2026, set the deposition for 29 Sep 2026, and listed 13 topics running from 1 Jan 2022 to the present. The labels have since withdrawn two topics and agreed to take a written certification instead of a witness for a third, which leaves 10.

Those 10 cover NVentures' business dealings with Suno before it invested, its reasons for joining Suno's Series C, the materials Suno gave it, what it knows about the contents and sources of Suno's training data, its diligence on training data, licensing and copyright risk, its existing analyses of licensing costs and of growth, its views on Suno's effect on the music industry and on the market for Suno's service, and one amended topic in the labels' own words: "Your communications with Suno concerning the risk of litigation related to Suno's training data."

The labels haven't filed their side yet. Music Business Worldwide reports their responses to this motion, and to a separate motion to quash from NVIDIA Corporation itself, are due on 24 Nov.

Why is an investor being asked at all?

NVentures says it shouldn't be. Per the filing, it was a minority investor in Suno's November 2025 Series C, which "closed more than a year after the underlying action began", holds "no board, observer, or advisory position", and had no role in choosing or using Suno's training data. It says it has already produced 6,324 documents (28,194 pages) without the labels identifying a gap. Everything else, it argues, should come from Suno, and opinions about the music market should come from the labels' own paid experts, not from an "unretained expert".

The motion leans on a September 2025 ruling in the labels' parallel case against Udio, where a magistrate judge wrote that courts have declined to order discovery of an investor's internal analyses when nothing suggested it held data not available from the company. MBW reports that the same ruling still ordered a16z to produce documents, because its partners had board and observer roles. That is the line NVentures is trying to stay on the right side of.

It isn't the only Suno investor in this position. MBW reports that Lightspeed, which led Suno's Series B and, according to the labels, holds a board seat, is also resisting a subpoena, and that the Boston court has already let the labels depose a former Menlo Ventures principal over a deleted social post. Timing matters too: the Boston court has extended the deadline for some already-noticed third-party depositions (those unrelated to the anti-circumvention claim) to 20 Nov 2026, the filing says.

For the wider picture of who is suing whom, see our AI music lawsuits explainer. This is the same case in which Suno admitted it kept its training recordings, and the same discovery fight that sent both sides after the MLC and DistroKid's data.

What we think

The topics tell you what the labels are after: a price. Four of the ten ask about licensing costs, growth, markets and industry effects. A growth-stage investor writing a cheque into a company already being sued by the major labels would be expected to model what happens if Suno must license its training data, and the amended topics ask for NVentures' existing licensing-related analyses. If those exist, they are a number someone with money on the line put on training rights, before any lawyer was asked to argue for one. It goes straight to the fair-use question of whether a licensing market exists, and to how much the labels lost by not being paid.

NVentures has a fair point that it is the wrong witness for Suno's engineering. On the price question, it is close to the right one. We expect the court to cut the broad "views on the music industry" topics and keep at least some of the narrow ones, especially communications with Suno about litigation risk, since those are facts about a specific exchange. That is our reading of the motion, not a prediction from anyone in the case.

The bigger signal is for the whole AI-music market. Discovery has spread past the AI company itself, to distributors, the MLC and the funds that backed Suno. Anyone funding the next music model should assume their diligence memo on training data could end up in front of a judge, and write it that way. For musicians, the odd result is that the most honest estimate of what their recordings are worth to AI companies may sit in a venture fund's files. If it does come out in court, it should be the starting point for any rate artists are offered, the case we made in AI music has a meter; artists need a rate.

Sources

  1. In re Subpoenas to NVentures, LLC and NVIDIA Corporation, 3:26-mc-80342 (N.D. Cal.), Dkt. 1: NVentures' motion to quash Rule 30(b)(6) subpoena (redacted public version), US District Court, Northern District of California (via Music Business Worldwide) (primary source). Accessed 13 Nov 2026.
  2. NVIDIA's venture arm asks court to block UMG and Sony's demand for testimony in Suno lawsuit, calling itself a 'passive minority investor', Music Business Worldwide. Accessed 13 Nov 2026.

Researched with AI assistance, written and checked by WATMM Desk.

Subscribe to We are the music makers

One email a week: the music-tech and AI-in-music news that mattered, and what we think about it.

Sign-ups open soon.