News · legal — By WATMM Desk —

UMG and Sony accept only a partial pause in their second Suno case, and want v6 discovery now

Suno wants the labels' second lawsuit, over more than 60,000 recordings, frozen until the court rules on fair use in the first. UMG and Sony agreed to defer ownership discovery but oppose a full stay, which they say could run into 2028. They want discovery now on how v6 was trained, Suno's licensing efforts, its investor presentations and its finances.

Key facts

  • What happened: on 30 Oct 2026 Suno moved to stay UMG Recordings v. Suno (1:26-cv-14275, D. Mass.), the labels' second case, until the fair use ruling in the first (1:24-cv-11611). On 13 Nov UMG, Sony and their labels filed a memorandum in partial opposition.
  • What the labels offer: defer work-specific discovery into ownership of the more than 60,000 recordings until the fair use ruling, and let all discovery from the first case count in the second.
  • What they want now: discovery on four subjects the first case does not reach: Suno's successor models including v6, its efforts to license training data, its commercial expansion and funding rounds (including investor presentations), and its recent finances.
  • Why it matters: according to the labels, the first case's record stops at Suno's models through v5.5, with limited v6 testimony. Under a full stay, they say, neither of their cases would examine how v6 was trained until after summary judgment in the first; motions there are due 22 Jun 2027.

Suno wants the major labels' second lawsuit against it put on ice. Universal and Sony will agree to a pause, but only for the part of the case that costs them the most work. In a memorandum filed on 13 Nov 2026, they accept that discovery into who owns the more than 60,000 recordings in the case can wait for the fair use ruling in the first case. What they oppose, in the filing's words, is "Suno's request that this action be frozen in its entirety, for a period that could realistically extend into 2028, while Suno continues to train, release, license, and monetize models that require independent scrutiny." Digital Music News reported the filing on 16 Nov.

What did Suno ask for?

A full stay. The labels filed the second case on 18 Sep 2026 after the court refused to add 61,026 more works to the first one, filed in June 2024 over 560 recordings. In its 30 Oct memorandum, Suno argues the new case brings "identical causes of action based on the same basic factual allegations," and that "the Court should stay UMG II pending resolution of UMG I to avoid the significant burdens and inefficiencies of duplicative and potentially unnecessary litigation." It points out that the court itself, in refusing the amendment, said discovery in a separate suit "could proceed on a different schedule, or indeed be stayed pending resolution of the fair use issue."

Suno also argues that the labels' "market dilution" theory, that AI output competes with their recordings even when it does not copy them, may not survive the first case. It cites Bartz v. Anthropic and the US government's statement of interest in the OpenAI litigation. If that theory falls, it says, both sides can stop spending on it.

What do UMG and Sony want instead?

A partial stay in three parts, per their filing:

  1. Ownership and chain-of-title discovery for the new works waits for the summary judgment ruling on fair use in the first case.
  2. Discovery goes ahead now on four subjects: Suno's successor models "including v6," its efforts to license training data, its "commercial footprint and business development," including "subsequent funding rounds and the presentations made to investors in connection with them," and its finances after the first case's record closes. The labels would give reciprocal discovery on the market for licensing recordings as AI training data and on how AI music affects the market for their works.
  3. Everything produced in the first case counts in the second, which the labels say removes "the duplication Suno claims to fear."

The reason is a gap in the record. According to the labels, the first case covers Suno's documents up to February 2025 and its models through v5.5, with only limited testimony on v6, which launched on 9 Sep 2026. "No Suno I witness has been designated to testify about how v6 was trained," the filing says. The complaint alleges v6 learned from outputs of Suno's earlier models and from user uploads. The labels warn that by the time discovery could start under Suno's plan, "the engineers who built the models may have moved on." The filing says that is already happening: the labels "recently learned that the engineer responsible for Suno's data scraping and training data acquisition has left the company."

If the court still prefers a broad stay, the labels ask for a fallback: a cross-use order now, a preservation order covering training datasets, model checkpoints and user-interaction data for every Suno model, and a stay that lifts automatically when the fair use ruling lands, not after appeals. In the first case, fact discovery closes on 20 Nov 2026 and dispositive motions are due 22 Jun 2027, both filings say. The 22 Jun 2027 date matches our AI music lawsuits explainer.

What we think

"Partial" undersells it. The labels are giving up the dullest part of the case, proving title to 60,000 recordings, and keeping the part that matters: how v6 was made, what Suno has tried to pay for, and what it told investors. That third subject is the same thing the labels are after when they press Suno's backers for testimony, as in the NVentures subpoena fight. A deck written to raise money is where a company says how big its market is and what its risks cost. Under the labels' plan, the second case becomes a way to reach Suno's 2025 and 2026 records, which, the labels say, Suno kept out of the first.

The best argument for Suno is the court's own words, and it isn't weak. The judge who will decide this floated a stay himself, and Suno is right that most of the second case rises or falls on fair use. But the labels have found the weak point: according to their filing, Suno argued in the first case that its recent models and deals were out of scope, and now argues the first case will settle claims about them. It cannot easily hold both. Our call, and it is only our reading, is that the court defers ownership discovery but orders at least a preservation order on v6 training data, so it doesn't end up ruling on a model nobody examined.

The labels just opened their own AI deals to discovery. Offering "reciprocal" discovery on their licensing of recordings to AI developers means Suno can ask how those deals were priced. The labels seem to want this: a working licensing market supports their argument that unlicensed training cost them a sale. Anyone negotiating an AI licence with a major should expect those terms to be argued in a Boston courtroom.

For people making music, the practical point is this: the legal status of a generator's newest model may not be argued until 2028. That is the difference with an AI DAW like Veena, where you build the song as tracks you edit yourself and, as its site puts it, "everything you make stays yours." For the other suits that could shape these rulings, see our AI music class actions tracker, and for what Suno has already admitted in this second case, Suno's admission that it kept its training recordings.

Sources

  1. UMG Recordings v. Suno, No. 1:26-cv-14275 (D. Mass.), Dkt. 37: Plaintiffs' memorandum of law in partial opposition to Suno's motion to stay (13 Nov 2026), US District Court, District of Massachusetts (via CourtListener RECAP) (primary source). Accessed 17 Nov 2026.
  2. UMG Recordings v. Suno, No. 1:26-cv-14275 (D. Mass.), Dkt. 31: Suno's memorandum of law in support of motion to stay (30 Oct 2026), US District Court, District of Massachusetts (via CourtListener RECAP) (primary source). Accessed 17 Nov 2026.
  3. UMG v. Suno II Battle Continues: Majors Push Back Against the Platform's Stay Motion, Seek 'Partial' Pause Pending the 'Resolution of the Fair Use Question', Digital Music News. Accessed 17 Nov 2026.
  4. Veena: meet your personal music producer, Veena Studio. Accessed 17 Nov 2026.

Researched with AI assistance, written and checked by WATMM Desk.

Subscribe to We are the music makers

One email a week: the music-tech and AI-in-music news that mattered, and what we think about it.

Sign-ups open soon.