Learn — By WATMM Desk —

Recording bass guitar: DI, amp or both

Record bass with a DI, a miked amp, or both on separate tracks. Both is the safest choice, as long as you check phase. We compared a manufacturer page with Sound On Sound guides from 1999 and 2022. Sources checked on 31 Oct 2026.

Key facts

  • A DI unit connects a high-impedance, unbalanced instrument signal to a low-impedance, balanced, mic-level input, so the signal arrives without room or microphone acoustics (Wikipedia, DI unit).
  • Sound On Sound's Paul White recommends a DI box with an input impedance of at least 500 kilohms, "preferably higher than 1MΩ", and says "the relative phase of the miked and DI'd sound has a profound effect on the final result."
  • Sound On Sound's Dave Lockwood (Aug 2022) says a plain bass DI "can often seem a bit bland and incomplete-sounding", and suggests a 6 dB dip near 1 kHz plus an 18 dB per octave roll-off at 30 Hz when blending it under an amp sound.
  • Radial Engineering describes its JDI passive direct box as flat from 10 Hz to 40 kHz and often chosen for high-output bass guitars.

Short answer: record both. Put a DI box between the bass and everything else, send one copy to the interface and one to an amp, and capture each on its own track. If you only have room for one, a DI is the safer choice for a home studio, and a miked amp is the more characterful one.

What a DI actually does

A DI (direct input) unit takes the bass's high-impedance, unbalanced signal and turns it into a low-impedance, balanced one that a mic input or interface can use. Wikipedia's entry on DI units describes it as connecting that instrument signal to a mic-level balanced input, usually over XLR, and notes the result is isolated from room and microphone acoustics. Passive boxes do this with a transformer. Active ones use a buffer or preamp and need a battery, mains or phantom power.

Bass is a place where the choice of box matters. Paul White's Sound On Sound guide to recording bass guitar says the right way is "a DI box with an input impedance of at least 500kΩ and preferably higher than 1MΩ", and that unless the bass has active pickups you cannot just plug into a mixer input and expect a good result. Radial Engineering's JDI is a passive example: the maker says it is flat from 10 Hz to 40 kHz and often chosen for high-output basses because it handles large signals without distortion. If your interface has an instrument (Hi-Z) input, that does a similar job for the DI route, and our guide to recording guitar at home explains how to find it.

Route 1: DI only

This is the simplest, quietest and most repeatable option. Nothing depends on a room, a microphone or a neighbour's patience, and you can change the tone at any time.

The cost is character. Dave Lockwood, writing in the August 2022 Sound On Sound piece on mixing DI bass, says a plain DI "can often seem a bit bland and incomplete-sounding". His measurements explain why: on a 1x15 cabinet the 500 Hz region sits more than 15 dB below the peak near 150 Hz, while the DI differs by only about 5 to 6 dB. A DI has more midrange and less thump than the same bass through a speaker. White makes the mixing point from 1999: the sound "tends to lose power when the other instruments are added to the mix unless the arrangement is very sparse."

A DI alone is a good fit for sparse arrangements, quiet flats, and anything you plan to run through an amp simulator later.

Route 2: miked amp only

A bass amp and cabinet colour the sound in ways a DI cannot. White notes that bass amps do not have flat frequency responses, so a DI'd bass will not sound like an amplified one without processing.

His mic advice is specific. Avoid general-purpose vocal mics, because most have "a deliberate low-frequency rolloff to compensate for the proximity effect." Use a non-vocal dynamic with a reasonably flat low end, or a dedicated bass or kick drum mic. He suggests starting about six to 12 inches in front of the best-sounding speaker in the cab, and says the brightest sound comes from pointing the mic at the centre of the speaker, with a warmer sound from moving it to one side. Our guide to microphone types covers why dynamic mics suit loud sources.

The risk is that the tone is now baked in. A miked amp is also the route most affected by the room and by volume, which matters in a flat. Our view: miked amp alone is the right call only when you are certain of the sound, and even then a DI costs almost nothing to add.

Route 3: both, on separate tracks

This is the standard professional answer, and it is the one we would give a home producer. White says that when you combine the two you can often use a smaller amp, because "the DI will provide all the bottom end you need." The amp supplies grit and midrange character; the DI supplies a solid, even low end.

How to set it up:

  1. Plug the bass into a DI box that has a thru output. Per Wikipedia, a thru jack passes the signal on so one performance can feed both the DI and an amp.
  2. Send the DI's balanced output to one interface input and mic the amp into another.
  3. Record each on its own track, so you can adjust their balance and timing later. Lockwood points out that separate tracks "will allow for subsequent time-alignment, if necessary."
  4. Check the phase before you mix (see below).

The phase check

The most common way to ruin this setup is to ignore phase. White says "the relative phase of the miked and DI'd sound has a profound effect on the final result, so you may need to phase-reverse one of the sources." In our reading, the mic is a little further from the string than the DI is, so its signal arrives slightly later, and the low end can partly cancel when the two are summed.

The practical check takes a minute. Solo both tracks, zoom in on the waveform of a plucked low note, and see whether the two line up. Then flip the polarity on one track and listen. Keep whichever setting sounds fuller and tighter in the low end. Our explainer on phase and polarity walks through the process.

Blending the two

Treat the amp as the main sound and the DI as support. For the case where the amp is a plug-in rather than a real cabinet, Lockwood suggests a broad 6 dB dip centred around 1 kHz (Q of about 0.3) plus an 18 dB per octave roll-off at 30 Hz on the DI, then blending it under the amp sound. His rule for the fader is practical: find "the minimum level at which adding the DI is audible", and if it does not improve the mix, leave it out.

This is our own reading rather than anything either writer says: the method works for real miked amps too. Start with the amp at a comfortable level, bring the DI up until the low notes feel steadier, then stop. The kick and bass sit in the same low end, so make the final call with the drums playing; our guides to low-end and bass mixing and the kick and bass relationship cover that stage.

What we think

Record both, always. The sources agree on the point that matters: a clean DI is cheap insurance, and a miked amp is a bonus. Where we disagree with the "just use a plug-in" crowd is on the amp itself. A real amp, even a small one at modest volume, adds movement and a sense of air that the DI alone lacks, and the DI covers for the amp's weaknesses at the bottom end.

One caveat on the sources: White's guide dates from 1999 and refers to hardware of that era, while Lockwood's is from 2022. The principles on impedance and phase hold up, but treat specific gear suggestions as dated, and trust your ears over any single number. The EQ values quoted here are starting points from one engineer, not rules.

A quick checklist

  1. Use a DI box (or interface instrument input) with an input impedance well above 500 kilohms.
  2. Use a DI with a thru output so one performance feeds both routes.
  3. Record DI and amp on separate tracks.
  4. Mic the amp with a flat-ish dynamic or bass drum mic, six to 12 inches from the best speaker.
  5. Check polarity and phase, and flip one track if the low end thins out.
  6. Blend the DI in only as far as it helps.
  7. Keep the clean DI, even if you love the amp sound. You can always reamp it later.

Sources

  1. JDI passive direct box, Radial Engineering (primary source). Accessed 31 Oct 2026.
  2. Recording Bass Guitar, Sound On Sound. Accessed 31 Oct 2026.
  3. Mixing DI Bass Guitar, Sound On Sound. Accessed 31 Oct 2026.
  4. DI unit, Wikipedia. Accessed 31 Oct 2026.

Researched with AI assistance, written and checked by WATMM Desk.

Subscribe to We are the music makers

One email a week: the music-tech and AI-in-music news that mattered, and what we think about it.

Sign-ups open soon.