News · legal — By WATMM Desk —
Reservoir widens its Suno and Anthropic suits to 2,511 songs, and adds Suno output evidence
Reservoir Media has filed amended complaints against Suno and Anthropic that raise the songs at issue from 1,903 to 2,511 and the damages claimed to about $446 million. The Suno complaint now includes 34 recorded examples of outputs Reservoir says infringe its songs.
Key facts
- What happened: on 11 Nov 2026 Reservoir filed first amended complaints in the Northern District of California. The Suno suit now lists 1,368 works (up from 1,050) and the Anthropic suit 1,143 (up from 853).
- Money: statutory damages claimed are $205.2 million against Suno and $171.45 million against Anthropic, plus two DMCA counts each; about $445.7 million across both suits, up from about $337.8 million.
- New evidence: Exhibits B and C to the Suno complaint hold 34 recorded Suno outputs, including one Reservoir says reprises the vocal melody of "Bring Me to Life", which it sets against Suno's own statement in another case.
Reservoir Media has made its two AI lawsuits bigger. On 11 Nov 2026 it filed a first amended complaint against Suno and a first amended complaint against Anthropic in the US District Court for the Northern District of California. Together they now cover 2,511 songs, up from 1,903 when the suits were filed on 21 Oct. Music Business Worldwide reported the filings on 13 Nov.
The plaintiffs are Reservoir Media Management, Inc., Reservoir Media Management (UK) Limited and Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. Limited. Both amended complaints say Reservoir owns 100% of, or exclusively controls, the US copyrights in every work listed in their Exhibit A. The Suno case now carries the number 4:26-cv-12305; the Anthropic case is 5:26-cv-12308.
What changed in the numbers
| Original complaint (21 Oct) | Amended complaint (11 Nov) | |
|---|---|---|
| Works listed against Suno | 1,050 | 1,368 |
| Works listed against Anthropic | 853 | 1,143 |
| Both suits | 1,903 | 2,511 |
Each complaint asks for actual damages and profits or, in the alternative, statutory damages of up to $150,000 per work wilfully infringed. Against Suno, that maximum is $205.2 million for 1,368 works, plus $3.42 million for circumventing access controls and $34.2 million for removing copyright management information. Against Anthropic, it is $171.45 million for 1,143 works, plus $2,857,500 and $28,575,000 on the same two counts. Added up, that is about $242.8 million against Suno and $202.9 million against Anthropic, or about $445.7 million in all, against about $337.8 million in the original filings.
The Suno complaint now brings its own output recordings
The original Suno complaint already alleged that Suno's outputs infringe, leaning on examples from other cases against Suno. The amended one adds Reservoir's own recordings. Reservoir says Exhibits B and C contain "34 recorded examples of Suno outputs directly infringing the Works", shared as video folders, and the notice of manual filing lodges them with the court as MP4 files.
The example it leads with is Exhibit B-1, a Suno output that Reservoir says reprises the "specific vocal melody" of Evanescence's "Bring Me to Life". It sets that against Suno's own motion to dismiss in the Isbell class action in Massachusetts, which, as the complaint quotes it, says that "by design and in practice" Suno does not "reprise specific melodies from songs someone else wrote". (Our earlier post covers the Isbell case.)
Two more allegations are new. On information and belief, the complaint says Suno "quietly" removed lyric search less than a year after launching it, which Reservoir says prevents rights holders from discovering the true extent of infringing outputs. And it quotes a since-deleted X post by C.C. Gong, described as a now-former principal at Suno's lead investor Menlo Ventures, who wrote that she had "shifted most of my listening to Suno". Reservoir uses it to argue that Suno competes with the music it was trained on.
The remedies are unchanged in kind: Reservoir still asks for impoundment or destruction of unauthorised copies, including those in training datasets and model weights.
The Anthropic complaint goes after rewrites
Apart from the added works and damages, the amended Anthropic complaint is largely unchanged from the original, which already made the argument below. It keeps its core claim that lyrics were copied to train Claude. Its sharper point is about the guardrails Anthropic added after music publishers first sued it in 2023. Reservoir says those filters cover "only a narrow subset" of well-known songs, and that while Claude Haiku 4.5 and Sonnet 5 decline to reproduce lyrics, they will rewrite songs "for a modern audience", which it calls unlicensed derivative works. It quotes a Claude Sonnet 5 response describing such rewrites as "edging past 'inspired by' into reproducing the copyrighted song, even when the words are swapped out". For the rewrite examples it cites Round Hill Music's August suit against Anthropic.
Neither amended complaint has been answered yet, and none of the allegations has been tested in court. MBW reports that an Anthropic spokesperson told Billboard in October that the company disagrees with the allegations and will defend the case vigorously.
What we think
More songs mostly raises the ceiling, not the odds. Adding 608 works lifts the totals pleaded across both suits by about $108 million, but $150,000 a work is the top of the range for wilful infringement, not a forecast. Reservoir still has to prove infringement and wilfulness work by work. A bigger list is leverage in a settlement conversation more than a guarantee in court.
The output exhibits are the part to watch. Training-data claims turn on fair use, where the law is unsettled and our first post noted a ruling in this same district that went against rights holders on training. A recording of an output that sounds like a specific song is a more familiar kind of copyright claim: does this track copy that one? Pinning Exhibit B-1 to Suno's own words in another court makes it harder for Suno to argue one thing in Boston and another in California. Whether the 34 examples hold up depends on what a court hears in them, which a complaint cannot settle.
Quoting a chatbot against its maker is a new tactic, and a weak kind of proof. A model's description of its own output is not a legal finding, and Anthropic will likely say so. What matters more is the underlying claim: that a filter blocking verbatim lyrics does not stop close rewrites. If that holds, "we block the lyrics" stops being a sufficient answer for any AI company.
For songwriters, the practical point is the same as in October. Any settlement or award goes to the publisher first and reaches writers through their contracts. If you are in Reservoir's catalogue, or any publisher's, it is worth asking how AI-related income would be classified and split. This is general information, not legal advice.
For more on this storyline, see our coverage of the original Reservoir suits, the Jason Isbell class action and Suno's licensed v6 era.
Sources
- Reservoir v. Suno, first amended complaint, No. 4:26-cv-12305, ECF 20, N.D. Cal., 11 Nov 2026 (primary)
- Reservoir v. Suno, notice of manual filing of digital media exhibits, ECF 21, N.D. Cal., 11 Nov 2026 (primary)
- Reservoir v. Anthropic, first amended complaint, No. 5:26-cv-12308, ECF 17, N.D. Cal., 11 Nov 2026 (primary)
- Reservoir expands copyright lawsuits against Suno and Anthropic to more than 2,500 songs combined, Music Business Worldwide, 13 Nov 2026
Sources
- Reservoir Media Management, Inc. et al. v. Suno, Inc., First Amended Complaint, No. 4:26-cv-12305 (N.D. Cal., filed 11 Nov 2026), ECF 20, US District Court, Northern District of California (via CourtListener) (primary source). Accessed 14 Nov 2026.
- Reservoir v. Suno, Notice of Manual Filing of Digital Media Exhibits (MP4 Videos), ECF 21 (filed 11 Nov 2026), US District Court, Northern District of California (via CourtListener) (primary source). Accessed 14 Nov 2026.
- Reservoir Media Management, Inc. et al. v. Anthropic PBC, First Amended Complaint, No. 5:26-cv-12308 (N.D. Cal., filed 11 Nov 2026), ECF 17, US District Court, Northern District of California (via CourtListener) (primary source). Accessed 14 Nov 2026.
- Reservoir expands copyright lawsuits against Suno and Anthropic to more than 2,500 songs combined, Music Business Worldwide. Accessed 14 Nov 2026.
Researched with AI assistance, written and checked by WATMM Desk.